Open Letter To Gold Investors: Will The Real Manipulator Please Stand Up (Free Article)

Last Monday’s flash crash in gold has predictably brought about commentary from the gold community.   Nanex has the up close details of how fourteen 338 contract sells were carpet-bombed into the Comex gold pit for maximum effect. Unfortunately, it appears that many of the folks who normally do their homework on gold activity seemed to regress into a pattern of blaming these dumps on the Fed and/or bullion bankers. Few, if any, commentators are looking at the actual reported data, such as the bankers participation report and commitment of traders, which points the smoking gun at speculators — or conceivably even a whale.  I use the term “slinger” to describe the activity.

The suspect for the indiscriminate attack behavior is again and again stated to be some powerful Oz-like central bank specifically the Fed.  Subsequently, participants in the precious metals market have considerable pause, which contributes to a loss of confidence. After all, if one thinks the causa proxima of this is JP Morgan/the Fed, then the response is duck and cover or even to hit the sell button on that GLD ETF.

Rather, the real debate should center on who is really conducting this gold attack activity. Financial journalists should be looking at this as well. Proper journalism would recognize that whales in a thinly traded market, which the Comex has become, is not a new concept. There have been recurrent offside rogue traders and whales in various markets throughout the last two decades. With the poor oversight regulation today, I believe markets are full of them. Such markets become highly distorted. The regulators should be checking into the source and position sizes of these trades. Will the real manipulators please stand up.

If it was revealed to be a rogue trader or a cartel of leveraged funds, the reaction of gold investors would be entirely different from malaise, duck and cover and discouragement. Since this is an open letter to the public at large (and I apologize to my subscribers for being redundant), let me state my case categorically and open it for intelligent discussion in the comments below. Please connect the dots with evidence as opposed to circular logic and opinion.

To that aim, here are my main points:

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s most recent banker participation report on positions as of Dec. 1 shows the U.S. banks as four participants. They are not identified by name, but historically and deductively, JP Morgan is the largest and most dominant participant. Over the last quarter this report has shown that the four big banks have continued to build a net-long position, now at 57,408 futures contracts, or 5.741 million ounces.

I have read comments that bullion banks don’t make directional bets; that they are effectively paper shufflers and trade skimmers. Oh? Still, there is a plausible second theory out there. Namely, it is that JPM is acting as an agent, or for agents, on behalf of the serious buyer of gold: the Chinese [see " China Successfully Hunts Where There is Gold "].

So is JP Morgan the short manipulator of gold some are continuing to suggest? At one time perhaps, but now I believe the answer is unequivocally “no” and,  in fact, the complete opposite. JP Morgan and the three other U.S. banks have a large net-long position equal to nearly 15% of Comex open interest.

The next forensic report shows managed money’s short position in gold. Here, we see the off-the-chart short position of the managed-money complex. I suppose a true conspiracy commentator might offer up that the Fed has an secret agent conducting business in this complex. But to that, I ask this question: What national interest is served by distorting the price of gold to such a degree that the Chinese can cheaply acquire thousands of tonnes, eventually announcing they have more gold than Fort Knox?

I prefer to call a spade a spade. The managed-money cohort is extremely short with a directional bet, and to such a degree that it points to a single slinger or group of slingers who are willing to throw thousands of short contracts into thin markets, with the bullion bankers taking the other side of the trade. In its early phase several months ago, these attacks had good success,in taking out long stops. Of late, this doesn’t seem to be working as well. Small speculators, who are traditionally long,  are now flat.

The chart shows this short position at its peak in mid December. Since then, the most recent Commitment of Traders report for positions on Dec. 31 shows slingers are short 74,421 contracts, or 7.442 million ounces. Contrast that with the four U.S. banks and ask yourself: Who is naked shorting into this market?

Chart source:  Gotgoldreport.com

Finally, if a whale or rogue trader was operating in the paper Comex market, we might expect to see price and supply distortions. Indeed, that is exactly what has happened. Currently, the Gold Offered Forward Rate, which is the rate at which dealers will lend gold against U.S. dollars, is in backwardation. That suggests tight physical supply and a measure of distrust in the so-called market.

One Month:   - 0.035%   (backwardation)

Two Months:   - 0.01667%  (backwardation)

Three Months:   - 0.00333% (backwardation)

I rest my case.

  • Taylor

    Nice post! Great details here. I enjoyed reading it. http://www.primebullion.co.nz

  • Dbest1

    The author does not explore the possibility that interest rates on treasury notes might be affected by positive sentiment in the PMs. There are some folks that have compelling arguments that gold is a competitor of sovereign debt. They are both (supposedly) conservative ways of deploying capital. One pays interest, one doesn’t. Lately the interest rates( payment for risk) have been low, mostly held low by demand, which has been high. If gold was not a tarnished commodity today, many more folks that care to store their wealth, would be buying the stuff. That would be a headwind for interest rates, causing less demand for bonds and interest to rise. The institutions that are making the most money on low interest rates are the ones that carry the highest leverage in the commodities sector. They would certainly lose a cash cow, if interest rates went significantly higher. They are making 100′s of billions of dollars, easily enough to justify a small loss of a million ounces of gold.

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Nanex run down of Monday’s gold flash crash:

    http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-01-08/proof-golds-latest-slam-was-not-fat-goldfinger#comment-4312860

    Obviously from one source.

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Minas Gerais rain forecast: some on Friday, but whole month of January looks dry.

    http://www.timeanddate.com/weather/brazil/belo-horizonte

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Not a strategic story, more weather related remediation, gawd.

    TORONTO, ONTARIO–(Marketwired – Jan. 8, 2014) – Carpathian Gold Inc. (TSX:CPN) (the “Corporation” or “Carpathian”) has temporarily suspended production at the RDM gold project, Brazil (the “Project”), which is wholly-owned by the Corporation’s subsidiary, Mineração Riacho dos Machados Ltda. (“MRDM”). The suspension follows receipt by MRDM of a temporary suspension of the Autorização Provisória de Operação (“APO”) which was previously announced on December 13, 2013. The conditions leading to the suspension of the APO are primarily the result of unusual recent heavy rainfall at the site. MRDM is working with SUPRAM to assess the extent of the remediation works required to have the suspension of the APO lifted. The Corporation will provide further updates in this regard as they become available.

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    CPN to reopen at 12:30 PT, half hour before close and in 25 minutes. No announcement as yet.

    http://www.stockwatch.com/News/Item.aspx?bid=Z-C%3aCPN-2136912&symbol=CPN®ion=C

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Kind of looks like CPN won’t reopen today, and being in Prague I am off to bed shortly after the close.

    Here is what I wrote up in early October. They burned through the PP money and borrowed more $, so the 40 cent takeout target would need to be adjusted about five cents lower. 35 cents would still be pretty distressed. CPN would keep the Romanian project in this scenario. A price in the 20s would be an eyeopener about valuations and really a travesty.

    http://winteractionables.com/?p=6324

  • John Chew

    I believe gold is suppressed by the gold leasing market due to negative gofo rates. Ironically, stress in the financial system is causing short term pressure on gold.
    http://www.alhambrapartners.com/2014/01/07/the-golden-range/

  • loantech

    Carpathian Gold halted at 8 a.m. PT
    Ticker Symbol: C:CPN

    Carpathian Gold halted at 8 a.m. PT

    Carpathian Gold Inc(C:CPN)
    Shares Issued 694,169,911
    Last Close 1/7/2014 $0.115
    Wednesday January 08 2014 – Halt Trading

    Carpathian Gold Inc. has been halted at 8 a.m. PT on Jan. 8, 2014, pending news.
    Russ I bet it is good news hoping for a price greater than your introduction price!

    • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

      Ok, just poured a stiff one. I hope it is a decent takeout.

      Chatter at Stockhouse: one investor (mooseslayer) who has been involved with this a long time says they had a board meeting yesterday. Guess we will see. They could just close their hedge book out for a big profit, pay Macquarie back and have cash to ramp up.

      http://www.stockhouse.com/companies/bullboard/t.cpn/carpathian-gold-inc

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Another solid delivery session in Shanghai: 362,845 ounces.

    Nothing taken out of GLD since Dec 30,