The Daily Deceit: Oh, What A Tangled Web They Weave

*** Free Rant ***

“’I was all for Obamacare until I found out I was paying for it.’ That’s America in a nutshell, isn’t it?”  wrote Mother Jones, citing a woman in a recent Obamacare article. This is what happens you incorporate Ministry of Truth propaganda into a mandate to obtain commercial health insurance.

Elsewhere the daily stinking pile of deceit, corruption and incompetence continues unabated.

The Hill reports, “A senior administration official on Monday rejected Intelligence Committee Chairwoman Diane Feinstein’s claim that the U.S. has halted intelligence collection against its allies. In a statement released earlier Monday, the California Democrat said that the White House ‘has informed me that collection on our allies will not continue.’ But the administration official called that statement ‘not accurate.’” 

It has taken more than two years for the media to finally understand the Obamacare fiasco. Now the Obama administration is squirming while the president takes off to go play golf. ARE THE RATS ABANDONING SHIP? 

Even NBC News ran a scathing story: “ Obama Knew All Along that Millions Would Lose Insurance .” If you are counting on “grandfathered insurance,” be sure to read the second paragraph below.

Four sources deeply involved in the Affordable Care Act tell NBC NEWS that 50 to 75 percent of the 14 million consumers who buy their insurance individually can expect to receive a ‘cancellation’ letter or the equivalent over the next year because their existing policies don’t meet the standards mandated by the new health care law. One expert predicts that number could reach as high as 80 percent.

“The law states that policies in effect as of March 23, 2010, will be ‘grandfathered,’ meaning consumers can keep those policies even though they don’t meet requirements of the new health care law. But the Department of Health and Human Services then wrote regulations that narrowed that provision, by saying that if any part of a policy was significantly changed since that date — the deductible, co-pay or benefits, for example — the policy would not be grandfathered.”

Ministry of Truth spokesman Jay Carney, without quantifying anything, tried to diminish it as follows:

“’ What the president said and what everybody said all along is that there are going to be changes brought about by the Affordable Care Act to create minimum standards of coverage, minimum services that every insurance plan has to provide, “  Carney said. “So it’s true that there are existing healthcare plans on the individual market that don’t meet those minimum standards and therefore do not qualify for the Affordable Care Act.”

The cancellation notices arrived just in time for Carney’s announcement Monday morning that the exchanges are now functioning properly. After prodding by the press, he admitted that four out of every 10 Americans may have to pay more for health insurance.

In the science of fallacious arguments, this falls under several categories:

– Argument By Fast Talking:  If you go from one idea to the next quickly enough, the audience won’t have time to think. Some psychologists say that to understand what you hear, you must for a brief moment believe it. If this is true, then rapid delivery does not leave people time to reject what they hear.

– Moving The Goalposts (Raising The Bar, Argument By Demanding Impossible Perfection) : If your opponent successfully addresses some point, then say he must also address some further point. If you can make these points more and more difficult (or diverse) then eventually your opponent must fail. It is also possible to lower the bar, reducing the burden on an argument.

– Argument By Selective Observation

– Argument By Half Truth (Suppressed Evidence )

Others favorites of this administration and the sistema are:

– Weasel Wording : This is very much like Euphemism, except that the word changes are done to claim a new, different concept rather than soften the old concept. For example, an American president may not legally conduct a war without a declaration of Congress. So, various presidents have conducted “police actions,” “armed incursions,” “protective reaction strikes,” “pacification,” “safeguarding American interests” and a wide variety of “operations.” Similarly, war departments have become departments of defense, and untested medicines have become alternative medicines. The book “1984″ has some particularly good examples.

I’ve also noticed they like to:

– Changing The Subject (Digression, Red Herring, Misdirection, False Emphasis): This is sometimes used to avoid having to defend a claim, or to avoid making good on a promise. In general, there is something you are not supposed to notice. For example, I got a bill that had a big announcement about how some tax had gone up by 5%, and the costs would have to be passed on to me. But a quick calculation showed that the increased tax was only costing me a dime, while a different part of the the bill had inexplicably gone up by $10. This is connected to various diversionary tactics, which may be obstructive, obtuse or needling. For example, if you quibble about the meaning of some word a person used, they may be quite happy about being corrected, since that means they’ve derailed you, or changed the subject.

– Argument From Adverse Consequences (Appeal To Fear, Scare Tactics) : Saying an opponent must be wrong, because if he is right, then bad things would ensue.

But none of this really changes the banquet of consequences. For example adjunct faculty, who make up about 75% of America’s teaching force at community colleges across the country, are getting their hours cut so colleges don’t have to pay health insurance costs. If the colleges had read the details of the bill, they’d know they’re already too late in the year to make such changes count.

Even if Obamacare enrollment is a dud, Medicaid enrollment is experiencing boom times. Under Obamacare, Medicaid is available for people who earn up to 133 percent of the federal poverty level, making many more people eligible. According to the WSJ, in Kentucky, for example, 82%, or 21,342, of those enrolling in new insurance plans under Obamacare are signing up for Medicaid, the Journal reported. In Washington, it’s 87 percent of 35,528; and in New York, 64 percent of some 37,000.

Whodathunk? A big pile on for subsidies and Medicaid with what remains of the younger middle class shelling out penalties for failing to enroll.

  • crimson

    Coffee: There is little doubt that the market will have a major decline once the top is in. Probably to the vicinity of the 200 day moving average. But blowoff phase could continue a little longer IMHO. Also I am thinking that expectations of Fed tapering will NOT be the driver of the looming bear.

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    A very good assessment. I had forgotten that youth under 26 can be covered under parent’s plan, so there goes another cohort. He also points out that a large chunk of younger people will be subsidized and thus a net drain on the system. That’s the rub, the big majority will be net drains. All Medicaid enrollments will skyrocket. Unmentioned are the large numbers whose employers have ended coverage and dumped them onto the exchange:

    Submitted by Peter Schoff via Euro Pacific Capital,

    Since Obamacare made its debut, discussions have focused on Ted Cruz’ efforts to defund the law and the shockingly bad functionality of the Website itself. Fortunately for Obama, polling indicates that Senator Cruz has lost, at least for now, the battle for hearts and minds. The President has not been nearly so lucky on the technological front. If current trends continue, the rollout may go down as the worst major product launch in history. But given the government’s enormous resources, it’s safe to say that the site itself will ultimately be fixed. But when it is finally up and running, the plan’s many deeper, and more intractable, flaws will come into focus. That’s when the fun will really begin.

    Put simply the program is built on a mountain of false assumptions and is covered by a terrain of unanticipated incentives. Any cleared-eyed observer should conclude that it is perfectly designed to raise the costs of care and wreck the federal budget. However, like just about every other complicated problem that bedevils the nation, the public has become far too caught up in the politics and has ignored the horrific details.

    Most people agree that the plan can only remain solvent if enough young and healthy people (“the invincibles”) agree to sign up. They are the ones who are likely to pay more into the system than they take out. But now that insurance coverage is guaranteed to anyone at any time (at the same price — even after they have gotten sick or injured), the only incentive for the invincibles to sign up will be to avoid the penalty (I think we can dismiss “civic duty” as an effective motivator). But as I detailed in a column last year, Justice John Roberts declared the law to be constitutional only because the penalties are far too low to actually compel behavior. Once young healthy people understand that they can save money by dropping insurance, they will. No amount of slick, cheerful TV ads will change that.

    The good news for Obama is that the plan will get a large percentage of young people covered. The bad news is that many of those that do sign up will not help the bottom line. The youngest and healthiest of the group are under 26 and will now be able to stay on their parents’ plans. This group will add nothing to the pool of premiums (but will use services). Among those older than 26, the ones who qualify for the largest subsidies will be more inclined to sign up. The way the plan is structured, individuals and families earning between 1.38 and 4 times the Federal poverty level will qualify for a subsidy. The government subsidy covers almost the entire premium for those near the bottom of that spectrum. These individuals will definitely sign up. But just like those under 26, they will be a net drain on the system.

    From my estimations, private premium contributions don’t surpass the government contributions until an individual or a family makes about 2.5 times the poverty level (which equates to about $28,000 for an individual and $55,000 for a family of 4). Since a very large percentage of young people earn less than that, many will sign up to get the benefit. But these people will likely be net drains to the system as well. Their total premiums paid may be more than the services they receive, but that may not be true when you look only at what they actually pay in.

    Young women, who plan on using maternity care, may also be motivated. But they can cost more than they bring in. The real cash cows are the young men, not covered by parents, who make more than 4 times the poverty level. But their only incentive to sign up is to avoid the penalty. But at just one percent of income, the penalty just won’t be a deciding factor. Most young men will save money by dropping insurance, paying the tax and incidental doctor visits out of pocket, and then only adding the insurance if and when something really bad happens.

    The subsidies in Obamacare kick in and kick out very abruptly. People finding themselves on the wrong side of a dividing line will face difficult choices that hurt the plan’s finances. The San Francisco Chronicle recently profiled a California couple in their early 60s making about $64,000 per year who would be able to qualify for a $14,000 annual subsidy by reducing their income by $2,000 dollars per year. It’s easy to imagine such individuals reducing their hours or their pay to qualify. Of course this type of behavior modification has not been anticipated by preparing premium and budget projections. It is no accident that the government has offered no serious projections about how much in healthcare subsidies it should expect to pay out over the coming years

    In truth, the premium levels themselves are based on nothing but assumptions. It is true that those lucky enough to actually get through the website’s technological maze have seen (unsubsidized) premiums that are lower than similarly constituted plans in the private market. But those low prices are only possible because no one knows what the new pool of insurance holders will look like. They assume it will look like the pools that already exist. But they won’t.

    Of course, the incentives for the young and healthy to drop out, and for the sick, old and the heavily subsidized to drop in will mean that the post-Obamacare pool will have very different actuarial arithmetic than the current pools. But all of that is as yet unknown. The numbers we see now were put there just to make us feel good. But once the economics kicks in, look for them to rise quickly.

    It is also ironic that high-deductible, catastrophic plans are precisely what young people should be buying in the first place. They are inexpensive because they provide coverage for unlikely, but expensive, events. Routine care is best paid for out-of-pocket by value conscious consumers. But Obamacare outlaws these plans, in favor of what amounts to prepaid medical treatment that shifts the cost of services to taxpayers. In such a system, patients have no incentive to contain costs. Since the biggest factor driving health care costs higher in the first place has been the over use of insurance that results from government-provided tax incentives, and the lack of cost accountability that results from a third-party payer system, Obamacare will bend the cost curve even higher. The fact that Obamacare does nothing to rein in costs while providing an open-ended insurance subsidy may be good news for hospitals and insurance companies, but it’s bad news for taxpayers, on whom this increased burden will ultimately fall.

    The real shock of Obamacare is not the unbelievable ineptitude in which it was launched, but the naiveté in which it was designed. The only thing worse than the product launch may be the product itself. But unlike other major entitlements, like Social Security and Medicare, that took years to produce red ink that was far in excess of original assumptions, the financial shortfalls in Obamacare should show up very quickly.

  • crimson

    Gold stocks pounded today with the juniors hit especially hard. And this despite consenus that the Fed will not taper anytime soon.

    A sustained bull in the gold sector will have to wait until the stock market clearly tops out IMHO. Not the slightest sign of that yet.

    • Coffee Trade

      Soon Crimson. I’ve been selling anything market related, even my kids college 529 mutual funds were unloaded this week, the top is NEAR.

      Those 2016 leaps on select miners are a nice option. GDX GDXJ

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Zero Hedge: Head Of World’s Largest Asset Manager Says Taper “Imperative” To End “Bubble-Like Markets”

    JPMorgan, Pimco, and now BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, all join the bubble warning chorus. From Bloomberg:

    FINK SAYS IT’S “IMPERATIVE” THAT THE FED BEGIN TO TAPER

    FINK CALLS MARKET `OVER-ZEALOUS’

    FINK SAYS THERE ARE “REAL BUBBLE-LIKE MARKETS AGAIN”

    So… when the three largest banks/asset managers in the US say that Ben Bernanke has blown the largest asset bubble in history and that the time to taper has come, will Janet Yellen once again turn a blind ear to warnings that come not just from the “tinfoil” blogosphere but the “respected” legacy financial institutions made up of serious people, and after the cataclysm admit that, just like last time, she “never saw it coming?”

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    *TAVENNER REFUSES TO TELL COMMITTEE ENROLLMENT DATA ON OBAMACARE
    *TAVENNER SAYS ENROLLMENT DATA WILL BE RELEASED MID NOVEMBER