With stock prices of most juniors trading as if their deposits are cow pasture in valuations, it now makes sense to incorporate the tax loss carryforward benefits that come with these shares. As these have been mounting while stock valuations shrink, I will be using this more actively in my screening process. To monetize this economic benefit would require takeovers or mergers with profitable entities as a non-profitable development firm can’t utilize them.
Corporate tax rates vary, but for purposes of valuing a carryforward I am using 30%. I am not a tax expert, but the example of Almaden (AAU) shows a combination of unused tax losses and tax credits that have not been recognized. It is unclear to me what the reporting rules are on this, but it is always found in the annual report, although it is commonly missing in the quarterly.
In most filings you will see the operating tax loss carryforward below the unused losses numbers. In AAU’s case, it has $11,907,000 in Canada expiring in 2029-2034 and $9,793,000 in Mexico. Note that the Mexico carryforwards expire in 2015 to 2024. This may account for the M&A activity in Mexico as firms seek to utilize this before they expire.
So in the AAU example, it has a total of $21.7 million in carryforwards. That would be roughly $6.5 million in tax-saving benefit to a profitable company. I use enterprise value as gauge the “market’s” valuation. This subtracts cash from market cap. AAU’s EV is about $52 million US.
Going through the names I use (listed below) makes one realize just how non-existent market efficiency is in this sector. Yes, the first order of business is to own the best deposits for the money; but when one sees a tax benefit consisting of a third or more of enterprise value, it gives one real head-scratching pause. In most cases you can quickly find EV with Yahoo Finance’s key statistic feature .
Note: I couldn’t find Victoria’s or Lydian’s numbers.
I will list in descending order firms with very high carryforward loss benefit to EV. For the benefit, use 30% or whatever tax rate you wish. These are in most cases year-end numbers, so they would now be higher.
Silver Bull : As of Sept. 30, 2014, $31 million U.S., $36 million Mexico (expires 2015-2024). Benefit $22 million. EV is $17 million, a rather shocking inefficiency for this advanced zinc-silver deposit in Mexico.
Vista : $59,062,000 U.S., so direct tax benefit would be roughly $19 million, yet EV is $19 million.
Sabina : $62.4 million (Canadian) in loss carryforwards that expire from 2031 to 2034. Benefit $20 million. Current enterprise value of Sabina stock is $42 million Canadian, or $35 million U.S. I am finding the valuation of this name particularly bizarre, even within the junior universe of other bizarreness.
Exeter : $33 million in carryforwards. Benefit $10 million. EV is $24 million.
Moneta : It states it has $5,751,000 non-capital losses available for deduction against future income. EV is $11 million.
Luna : $42.8 million Canada and $5,827,000 Brazil. Benefit is $16 million. Yet today shyster Leduc gives away the store, more later on that.
Bear Creek : $27,816,000 Canada 2026-2033 and $13,339,000 Peru indefinite. Roughly $14 million benefit. EV is $78 million.
Continental Gold : My largest position, had end of 2014 tax loss carryforward of $127 million in Canada expires 2030, $14 million U.S. in Colombia. That’s $144 million Canadian, and it is no doubt higher a third of the way through 2015. That’s $43 million immediate benefit for an acquirer. CNL’s enterprise value (EV) is $228 million Canadian.
Chesapeake Gold : $14.2 million Canada, $4,840,000 Mexico.
Pilot Gold : (see below)
Seabridge : $41,713,000 Canada 2034.
Balmoral : $11,991,000 Canada.
Asanko : (see below)
True Gold : (see below)
Gold Standard : (see below)
Pretium : $66,172,000 Canada tax loss carryforwards 2030-2034, and 7,222,000 in tax credits.
I invite you to join Winter Watch and Actionables for only $35 per quarter . Your subscription grants you full access to the Winter Watch and Actionables website.