Smithsonian Channel’s Treblinka Archaeology Propaganda

The film “ Treblinka: Hitler’s Killing Machine ,” featuring so-called archaeological forensics expert Caroline Sturdy Colls, makes a mockery of historic research. The board of the Smithsonian should be ashamed of itself for associating with this deeply flawed work.

In summary, Colls

— flies over Treblinka with a team operating state-of-the-art ground-penetrating radar to reveal its mass burial and wood pyre cremation site,  said to be one of the largest in the world. However, (oops!) the radar actually reveals there is no disturbance suggesting a mass burial site .

(Note: Some say the total volume of earth removal required to bury 900,000 people, meaning dirt plus wood ashes plus human remains, would be 167,200 m³. The forest around Treblinka is comprised of fir and pine, which doesn’t burn unless well dried, and there is limited evidence of large deforestation in the area.)

— examines maps drawn by self-proclaimed extermination eye witnesses, but none of the maps match. Each has different scales and point to different burial site locations.

— goes and digs up human bones in an old Catholic cemetery nearby after Jewish rabbis restrict digging at the Treblinka camp. She declares these to be Jewish victims.

— continues digging at a rabbi-approved location within the site. Her team unearths a fossilized shark’s tooth. Note that 900,000 victims equal about 25 million human teeth. Not one human tooth was found.

— unearths two broken terracotta tiles with a stamped star. Though the stamped symbol is the brand mark of a Polish terracotta manufacturer, she declares it as the star of David and concludes the tiles must be from Treblinka’s notorious gas chambers.

Treblinka mass burial monument constructed of black stones to visually illustrate charred wood and remains.

— goes to the mass burial memorial and picks up off the ground a few tiny bone fragments, which she presents as more evidence of mass extermination. She completely ignores the fact that visitors frequently (and illegally) sprinkle cremated remains of relatives at the memorial.

If not a mass extermination site, then what was Treblinka? According to Shoah Center interviews with survivors, it was merely a stopover. At Treblinka, prisoners were cleaned up, fed and looted of their personal possessions before being transferred to other destinations.

It’s important to highlight that the mockumentary was produced by the  Smithsonian Channel , a joint-venture LLC between Smithsonian and CBS ‘ Showtime channel. The majority shareholder in CBS is  Sumner Redstone  (aka Sumner Rothstein).

  • Brabantian

    In nearly half the EU, denying the Holocaust is a criminal offence, with even disparaging the events, rendering a person vulnerable, in proceedings where truth or factual argumentation are not acceptable as defences.

    Of 48 countries in Europe (from Black Sea coast westwards), 15, less than one-third, have Holocaust denial laws. However, of 28 countries in the EU, nearly half, 13, have denial laws, mostly in middle latitudes, while ones without such laws are all of Scandinavia, UK & Ireland, plus Estonia & Latvia in the north; and in southern Europe, Spain, Italy, Greece, Cyprus, Malta, Slovenia, Croatia, & Bulgaria, do not have these laws.

    Seems Israel is the only place outside of Europe with such a law, and only Switzerland & Liechtenstein in Europe outside the EU. EU countries with denial laws are Austria, Belgium, Czechia, France, Germany, Hungary, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, and Romania.