Gold Shares’ Heavy Liquidation: Really?

What is the heavy looking “liquidation” all really about? GDXJ traded 13.9 million shares Wednesday in an awful session. GDXJ is a $2.2 billion vehicle. Twenty percent of the total market cap in one day, seriously? Constant machine gun bursts of 100-200 share trades. Obviously 500-share retail selling can’t cause this, so is this a monstrous institutional dump going on?

Indeed, one aspect I have been watching closely is institutional activity, as well as major insider action. We also know private placements bring out sellers, but there has been a dearth of that lately. There is little serious insider selling going on, and in fact clusters have appeared in several stocks, and I have reported on it.

Gold Standard (GSV) insider buying cluster

From the disclosures, I have spotted only isolated institutional selling in the stocks. There was one good size dump of 30.8 million shares from Sentry in Teranga. Sentry is more an activist shareholder that tries to get on boards, so I am guessing they were unsuccessful on that front and decided to move along. I have heard Brazilian investors may be behind the crash in Luna Gold. Other than those instances, I see little else.

Gold stock mutual funds are tiny nowadays and can’t account for the alleged liquidation. The 17 major funds  have about $13 billion in them, really only an afterthought. They have long since been liquidated.

That leaves the usual suspects: hedge fund and algo gaming of indexes like GDX and GDXJ, resulting in market makers evaporating and discouraging natural buyers.

I don’t want to just make excuses as the biggest disappointment in this sector is the lack of scarfs, or takeovers. That serves as a check and balance against slinger abuse and is a serious issue. In fact, one would think large shareholders and institutions are angling for monetizing these hyper-depressed assets. I think Luna Gold is a good example of this, and I bought more of that at 35 cents U.S.  When these come (in this small universe of real prospects), they should go off at very high premiums to current hyper-depressed levels.

Fundamentally, I see very little to be disappointed with. Lower energy and material prices lower operating and capex costs for miners and developers. That’s a good thing.

— Pilot found a third porphyry  at TV Tower. These results may not be immediate game changers, but they are incremental and do not justify an 8% stock drop.

— True Gold is making excellent progress and showing improved economics , yet it traded at a new low. I bought more at 27 cents U.S.

— Pretium  hit row after row  of 100+ grams and even 1,000+ gram intervals at depth, and yet the stock got trashed. Nonsensical.

— African Barrick is  being transformed into a pretty darn good miner , yet its stock is absolutely on its ass.

-Barisan’s last hole #12 was its second best yet and the stock continues to trade at a $4.5 million enterprise value. I bought more at 14 cents Canadian.

And in my world, good news is exactly that, good news. Right now it seems that great news takes the price down even more. I can’t describe this as “more selling” as Pilot’s $341,000 in trading yesterday doesn’t really qualify as “liquidation” or “selling.” That’s not what this is. It is really more of a vacuum and Pilot is part of the indexes that are being abused.

Wash, rinse, repeat in the Crimex complex

Silver was trashed again, yet open interest rose 2,714 contracts to 172, 906. That’s not liquidation folks, it is accumulation in the face of more paper shorts being offered up.

And how about the U.S. Mint silver eagle sales as a tell? With seven days still left in the month, looks like the best month of the year is in the cards.

Elsewhere in the world of “liquidation,” silver producer First Majestic is withholding 954,000 ounces from the market due to price.

Gold had a rough day but only shed 253 contracts. Again, that is not a “liquidation.” GLD was extracted for 2.1 more tonnes yesterday. That will feed China for about 1/5 of one session nowadays. Again, not a “liquidation” but rather parasite guild insider fraud. Shanghai deliveries were 29.66 tonnes in the last three sessions, which is hardly “poor demand.” In fact, since the Golden Week holiday, deliveries at SGE are up 50% from average.

Central Fund of Canada closed at 8.1% discount to NAV. That kind of a discount is definitely a tell on sector psychology.

In a sudden about face , China said it’s going to scrap its proposed coal tariffs on Australia. Looks like concessions were granted and bribes paid. There is a free trade deal coming, and I bet China makes asset grabs in Australia. Vista Gold (VGZ) is more than ripe.

  • John

    Russ, the build in silver open interest over the past year has coincided with a decline in prices. It is my understanding that in general, an increase in open interest supports the current trend. If this is right, we would need to see a flattening or decline in open interest for the price trend to change. Can you explain why you see the continued build in open interest as bullish for silver?

    • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

      I am mostly looking at various aspects of liquidation. Rising OI is not associated with a liquidating market. It is not an immediate or exact indicator of a trend change, but can provide hints of the underlying building demand structure.

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter
  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Biotechs are up 11.5% since Janet Yellan rattled her gums about “pockets of bubbles”. Friday is the last QE operation, nothing to follow unless the Fed extends it Wednesday. ECB is just jawboning about QE as their banks are in huge trouble Meanwhile la de dah.

    http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2014-10-23/biotechs-hit-record-high-115-yellens-stretched-valuations-warning

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter
  • IAC

    Lower oil is not is 100% positive for gold imo. While costs come down inflation concerns abate overall. If markets are trending sideways to higher and financial system not melting down sheep see little reason to own gold. Gold needs more than verbal jawboning from FED to come alive. I have no doubt China demand will matter at some pt, but gold above ground gold is massive compared to annual supply so basing gold price on costs/demand is a fools game in the ST/IT. Sure the shares are a great value (at some pt), but ignoring the whole market in favor of gold seems overly biased. Call me a contrarian indicator if you want. And yes I’m feeling rather gloomy towards the yellow metal. Gold share action relative to gold and SPX has been abysmal. Tax loss selling at least in juniors will extend all the way thru Dec.

  • loantech

    XAU:GOLD lower than anytime since prior to 1993 as far back as my chart goes.

    • IAC

      Charts like this are really deceptive unfortunately, although I use them too. How many shares have been issued since then? Would like to see a market cap version or enterprise value version of the same chart. Don’t think the data exists. Companies are ridiculously cheap, but if gold goes to fresh 52 week lows and markets don’t completely fall apart they’ll get cheaper still. Forget buyouts need mergers and consolidation. Majors need to come together and hold back production and juniors need to merge so they don’t get stolen. Doubt either is going to happen to any meaningful degree ST. They all care too much about their cushy jobs.