Peak Ponzi (and Anti-Ponzi)

Free The No. 1 question I asked Friday as silver was forced through the trap door on the chart: What would happen with the big, strong longs in that complex? If the intent of the short attack was to force a capitulation of this long or longs (Chinese proxies?), you would finally expect to see a sizable drop in silver open interest (OI).

This number can be tracked here , and on Friday it showed yet another increase of 3,776 in silver futures OI to 177,289. This is hardly a sign of strong longs forced to capitulate or being stopped out. In fact, it illustrates quite the opposite. The strong longs (regardless of who he is/they are) simply added to their position from naked paper sells or shorts provided by managed money slingers.

This is also illustrated by the Commitment of Traders (CoT) numbers from last Tuesday . In the Sept. 9-16 week, the managed-money slingers short position increased by 5,168 contracts to a new record of 42,249. If we go back into the Crimex data from last Tuesday, we see silver OI was 171,260. Since Tuesday and through Friday’s action, we witnessed silver OI expand by 6,000 throughout what was obviously a concerted short attack. If this was a long liquidation, this should have gone down, not up.

From the silver OI increase, we can hazard an educated guess that slingers are up to about 48,000 naked short contracts (240 million ounces). With this wild onslaught, they have forced a lower price but without dislodging the strong long/longs one iota, instead giving them even more cheap silver. The strong longs appear to be playing rope-a-dope. Somebody is going to lose this game of chicken and my bet is it will be slingers. Am I surprised they tried it to this extent? Absolutely, but they will ultimately lose this gambit.

The same general pattern can be seen in gold. The CoT showed managed money shorts up to 73,364 contracts. A total of 14,863 new short contracts were added to take price of gold (PoG), down from $1,256 (from $1,236 on Tuesday, the report date).

Crimex gold open interest is currently at low levels, which to me signals serious gold investors are using that exchange less and less. And with the new international exchange in China, that trend should continue. But despite the further drop in PoG to $1,217 at week’s end, OI increased slightly to 386,744 from 386,080, including 2448 more on Friday. Again, that is not the hallmark of long liquidation but of longs buying more paper shorts. Most likely the managed money/slingers have pushed their Crimex gold, naked shorts to at least 80,000 contracts (8 million ounces, or 227 tonnes) and maybe much higher, to a new record.

About 7.78 tonnes of gold, or roughly 1% of the total, was extracted out of  the GLD Friday. Inventory, if indeed it is really there, is reported as 776.44 tonnes. Given that this is about equal to the appetite for one day’s delivery on the Shanghai Gold Exchange — and now we have the new international gold market opened in China — it would seem plausible that gold will continue to move east and be sourced out of GLD. This will be a real test to see how much real gold really remains in GLD that isn’t just script and leased out IOUs.

On Friday, the Central Fund of Canada (CEF)  traded at negative 8.8% to NAV. Since the gold and silver in this fund is real and fixed, a discount this large is a measure of North American investor sentiment.

Simply put, that sentiment suggests a proclivity to chase into Ponzi units (BABA, etc.) and avoid anit-Ponzi units (actual gold and silver). However, as illustrated in the analysis above, I do not really accept the premise that precious metals investors are actually long liquidating to chase the BABA-like Ponzi units.

I haven’t coined this “Peak Ponzi” for nothing — and it’s especially ironic given that QE support is drying up. Also telling is that timed with the end of QE, 44 venture capital start-up companies are in the IPO pipeline with a valuation of more than $1 billion each, despite no earnings and scarce revenues.

Although not on many radar screen or mentioned in the press, I am also focused on the Nov. 30 Swiss Gold Referendum. Given that this would involve buying 1,700 tonnes of gold to reconfigure the Swiss Bank’s reserve holdings, it would be a game changer.

This is especially true in a market where a few tonnes has to be rounded up from dark corners of empty western vaults and against a backdrop of huge managed money/slinger naked short positions. In addition, Swiss gold, allegedly stored in Canada and London, would also have to be returned to Swiss custody. With 104 tonnes of Swiss gold at the Bank of Canada and 208 tonnes in the Bank of England, that would be an exercise we can only imagine.

King World News conducted an interview with Egan von Greyez, a veteran 42-year money manger located in Switzerland. He made the following statement. I do find it a little hard to believe that the cabal will let this one go without a fight. If not, it could signal that the cabal was already well-positioned for such an outcome.

I’ve been in discussions with the people behind the Swiss Gold Initiative and I think they stand a very good chance of winning their referendum on November 30. There is no real opposition. The Swiss have always had an affinity for gold.”

* * * * * * *

Visitors, a subscription to WinterActionables.com is only $35 a quarter. If you are exploiting the current once-in-a-generation opportunities in precious metal stocks like I am, less than $12 a month is a bargain to have keen eyes on this sector, which is being absolutely neglected and barely followed.

  • prattner

    I figure the most perverse thing that could happen right now is for the POG to go up. That would burn and piss off the greatest number of short term traders. So that’s what it will do :)

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Very well put Ponzi commentary:

    Excerpted from John Hussman’s Weekly Market Comment,

    http://www.hussmanfunds.com/wmc/wmc140922.htm

    When the most persistent, most aggressive, and most sizeable actions of policymakers are those that discourage saving, promote debt-financed consumption, and encourage the diversion of scarce savings to yield-seeking financial speculation rather than productive investment, the backbone that supports a rising standard of living is broken.

  • prattner

    So, what does everyone here think will happen? It seems that just about everyone interested in gold now things we are about to see new lows, maybe even today. Silver has broke already. The dollar is reaching new highs, the Yen is reaching new lows, China has opened their new gold market, there’s wrangling over how to fix the price of gold again…

    It feels like something is up. I’m particularly interested in the Chinese actions–that seems to be accelerating.

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter
  • loantech

    Russ is the meat of this article sour milk or cream? This guys does not seem to like gold for now or juniors and has on of the recent bigger names floating in the resource world?

    I see him and that smarmy Rick R. as trying to spook and rake in all the cheapest shares they can BWTHDIK?

    http://www.kaiserresearch.com/s/KaiserBlog.asp?ReportID=675360

    • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

      I think that article reads as incoherent gibberish.

      You know I believe there are paid psyops all over the map in money and finance as well as elsewhere. If they do it in human trafficking such as the Dutroux case (see my post), doing it here is a given.

  • bb

    russ i have not posted in quite a while. I am a deep value investor that uses stop losses and thank god i have. Many many small cap value situations and commodity stocks have been destroyed. Long term bases are being taken out. I follow coal very closely and i have to say it is the most extreme hatred i have seen toward a commodity in a while. Its worse than gold and silver. I would love to see you turn your attention to other areas of the market other than gold and silver given the opportunities that are being created.

    • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

      I would be interested in hearing your points for a bull case.

      I think the coal situation is dependent on two things: 1, political, and as long as a Cloward and Piven practitioner is in office, coal will be suppressed. We need to see a political light at the end of the tunnel. 2. The popping of the fracking nat gas credit bubble and over emphasis on NG. . That bubble is Ponzi financed, maladjusted and will go down with the general bursting of junk and credit market. Once that bubble actually bursts, then one could look for coal to be in the wings to benefit.

      It may not seem so to most, but I see the payoff in precious metals as being more immediate, an example was mentioned in today’s post.