The Boston Marathon bombing offers up more examples of questionable images of casualties. One of the more glaring of these is the wheeling off of an individual named Jeff Bauman. He was filmed and photographed as having his legs blown off below the knee.
I requested comments from some medical professionals I know — and welcome yours as well — about whether it is possible for someone in this condition, facing this sort of medical crisis, to be conscious, sitting upright in a wheelchair and not bleeding.
The answers I got back were generally as follows:
1. Proper medical protocol would have been to put him prostrate on a stretcher, not in a wheel chair. Marathon events are usually well supplied with both, as well as trained emergency teams that should know what they are doing.
2. Shock would be difficult to avoid even if a tourniquet was properly and quickly applied. But Bauman laid on the sidewalk for 8 minutes before he was removed and still fully conscious. Incredibly lesser injured people were carried off on stretchers before Bauman was taken in a wheel chair. He would have likely bled to death during that time or, at minimum, would have gone into shock from blood loss. One professional told me that within a few minutes half or more of Bauman’s blood would have left his body through his femoral arteries if not immediately treated.
I have found an account and a video (too gory to post) of blasted off lower legs without bleeding, but there is evidence of charring and burning in those cases. Jeff Bauman’s femoral artery is visible in the fingers of the guy in the cowboy hat. In comparison to the real thing, Boston looks very contrived.
But here’s where it gets really gets really perplexing. There are few photos pre-Boston Marathon of Jeff Bauman anywhere on internet. However there are hundreds of photos of an amputee soldier by the name of Nick Vogt. The resemblance between Baumann and Vogt is striking.
Take a look, is Nick Vogt shown on the left and on the right below a completely different individual than injured Jeff Bauman on the left and below? The Vogt photo looks like a bit thinner individual and of course Bauman has a full head of hair. A google search for facial recognition expert and Bauman/Vogt reveals nothing of consequence on the internet, so there is no absolute certainty.
Nick Vogt has been accused of being an actor, so this looks to me like another instance where he could be properly and justly cleared or implicated one way or another by independent recognition experts. Unfortunately this has not been conducted, leaving a mystery. There are also Bauman interviews and he has a distinctive accent and speech pattern. I have looked high and low for a voice recording of Vogt without luck.
Separately, Jeff Baumann receives over $360,000 in donations.
Regardless of the Vogt question mark, the strange fumbling around with the hooded man after the blast
looks very suspect.
Is Jeff Baumann and/or the hooded man putting on some type of device over his clearly visible clean stump right after the explosion? Is it a tourniquet? As the story goes that was applied by the cowboy hat guy. In reality there should be large spurts of blood from this torn wound in the seconds after the blast. The people around him would be saturated. Instead we see a strange hooded person carrying something in his left hand hovering over Baumann. Notice a woman’s head between Baumann and the hooded man. You decide. Here is the full video sequence.
Here is a photo taken about ten seconds after the blast showing what I count as eight hooded individuals at the location of the explosion. I call them “Team Hoody”. What are they doing? Does this look expected or normal? You decide.
I have my own opinion, but you decide if these people photographed after the blast look faked.
Have a look at what staged military pyro-technic explosions with amputee actors looks like.