Dragonslayer Podcast: Occam Razor Applied Against Conspiracy Theory Labeling

* Free Podcast*

This inaugural podcast asks the question as to why conspiracy theory labeling is thrown back as a derision strategy during discussion or conversation about issues like the JFK coup,  9/11, Sandy Hook, etc. The obvious answer is that such labeling is good propaganda and effective mind conditioning to control the sheeple. However, h istory should not be a lie agreed upon by the media, the politicians and others of influence.  So in this podcast, I apply the concept of Occam’s Razor to the issue. This states that among competing hypotheses, the one with the fewest assumptions should be selected. Other, more complicated solutions may ultimately prove correct, but—in the absence of certainty—the fewer assumptions that are made, the better.

I believe the primary assumption surrounding so-called conspiracy theories is that banal, evil agents and actors have used government and power since time immemorial to plot, scheme, loot, murder, exploit, carry out coups and takeovers, and to otherwise control and manipulate populations. In fact, if history has proven one thing, it is that such intrigues and conspiracies are the rule rather than the exception.  Are we to believe that because of some notion of American exceptionalism, that the U.S. is given an exemption to this great rule of history? The debunkers need to address this first and foremost before just making a lazy dismissal of the better researched conspiracy practices. The fundamental proposition and lenses I view events though is that there are evil, banal people running the show, so why would a Sandy Hook Hoax and more be a big surprise?

On the other hand, as an example, the narrative of strange lone nuts gaining access and managing to squeeze off a few rounds to assassinate leaders requires a lot of assumptions to make it work.  Explaining how three huge skyscraper towers can just collapse at near free fall speed not only requires complex assumptions but a reinvention of the laws of physics.  And explaining away the often blatantly organized official cover ups of these plots requires even more complex and ludicrous assumptions and is a direct contradiction of Occam’s Razor.  Simply put, obfuscation and cover up are solid assumptions that a conspiracy practice is in play.  These cover ups are now incredibly documented, and that fact is a key factor when looking at these cases.

The Audacity recording on this is very clear quality, but is also loud, so I recommend turning down the volume.

  • BreakOut

    Nor do I have exclusive insight into Marina’s brain….only she knows what she was thinking.

  • BreakOut

    Of course, this is all speculation on my part. Tosh Plumlee may be telling the entire truth. I have no proof to deny it. Madelyn Brown or Judith Vary Baker may be telling the entire truth. I have no proof to deny it. This is all pure speculation on my part, and an observation that everyone cannot possibly be telling the truth. Somebody is lying, but I do not know who it is nor do I have have any evidence to prove it.

  • BreakOut

    I went through about a two year period where I was convinced JFK was a conspiracy. Some of the most interesting trails were followed, including declassified (but highly redacted) minutes from meetings in 1963, including Nixon and mafia connections on some obscure Cay. Accounts by Tosh Plumley piloting Johnny Roselli into Dallas on November 22, 1963. Accounts of Oswald’s CIA and or mafia connections. A picture of David Ferrie with Oswald in 1955 New Orleans Civil Air patrol. Accounts of Jack Ruby meeting at Lamar Hunt’s office on November 21. Accounts of Oswald tooling around Louisiana with fellow conspirators the summer of 1963, including at the mental hospital in Clinton. Accounts by Madeline Brown, LBJ’s jilted paramour, that he squeezed her arm the night before the assassination and strongly implied that JFK would get his the next day.

    The problem with all of this is that they are totally inconsistent with Oswald himself. Most modern scientific studies have ruled out a second gunman. High resolution video enhancement clearly shows a stream of brain material shooting up and forward from JFK’s head at the fatal shot. Three shots came from the School Book Depository, and no others were fired.

    So, if Oswald was the centerpiece of ANY kind of a conspiracy, why did he only have four bullets on him for a six clip rifle? Why did he leave his pistol home if it was not something he decided to do Thursday AM after reading the paper at work? Why did he lie about everything?

    Oswald was an idealist who just wanted to get into his next paradise, Cuba, but the only problem was they didn’t want him. They threw him out on his ass when he panicked during his September visit to their embassy in Mexico City, as did the Russians. Now, all he had, a pretty wife, was sick enough of him that she was cutting loose. She wanted to learn English and spend more time with American men who had money than the controlling loser who kept her on a chain. He made one last appeal to her, but she declined him. He was at the end of his rope. And other than George De Mohrenshildt, who had been in Haiti since shortly after Oswald’s shot at General Walker in April (per Marina’s testimony, Oswald was indeed a political assassin), Oswald had never been able to cooperate with anyone long enough to be a partner in anything, let alone a major conspiracy. He was totally unsuitable for the CIA, KGB or anything. Study him. Listen to his tapes. He is intelligent, but a total one man operation.

    Although there is a lot of shameless self promotion at the beginning, this is a pretty good summary video. All of those other threads lead to only one conclusion: people lie. Tosh Plumley has made a life’s work of spinning yarns – when interest in JFK died down, he was suddenly in the middle of the drug trade. He likes to talk. Madelyn Brown was dropped like a rock with a kid in tow from LBJ, how does she get even? Judith Vary Baker was a pretty, gifted teen who turned plain – does she really believe the yarns she spins?

    Reclaiming History. 53 pieces of Evidence against Oswald.

    image

    Reclaiming History. 53 pieces of Evidence against Oswald…

    View on

    Preview by Yahoo

  • mikeginn

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/16/sandy-hook-conspiracy-theory-video-debunked_n_2487427.html

    I believe some conspiracy theories are fact, but not others.
    Possible: JFK killed as in “JFK and the Unspeakable,” Syrian chem weapons attack was a false flag to provide an excuse to bomb Syria, the Lakers’ 27 Free Throws in the Fourth Quarter of Game 6 Against the Kings were to give the NBA a better viewed Finals, Dwyane Wade’s Shooting as Many Free Throws as Dallas in Game 5 of the ’06 Finals due to grudge against Dallas owner
    Probably not: Sandy Hook staged for political gain, 9-11 orchestrated by US, Roswell aliens and landing craft, NASA moon landing staged

    • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

      On your probably nots : Sandy Hook and 9-11 are not even remotely in the same class as NASA and Roswell.

      Yes, basketball games fixes by refs is real and getting worse.

  • IAC

    It’s your blog do what you want. But personally I’d only like to see posts that impact the market at this point. Even if I agreed with your Sandy Hook premise it has no impact on the market/economy at this point. There are enough tragic school shootings/senseless murder in general so not sure why they would need to stage more. Even after SH we still can’t get any meaningful changes in gun laws so seems like a lot of work w/no payoff if that was the case. 9/11 dramatically changed the landscape w/respect to personal rights/surveillance – completely different from SH on so many levels. There are enough examples of unfair play in the markets (HFT) that there’s little need to search out other areas of interest (again my opinion).

    • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

      I can post about gold until the cows come up and have. You are totally up to date on anything I feel is relevant. These markets are not following normal patterns, Heck I see the JGB didn’t even see private trades over the last 36 hours. Beyond bizarre, but how does one evaluate that?

      • Coffee Trade

        In the case of Sandy Hook, what do you surmise the end game is? What are “they” trying to accomplish? Just fear and chaos? Changing gun laws in the US? Please elaborate. I’m not against a conspiracy theory, its just that I’m not sure what’s gained by this one.

        And how would all the “actors” keep quiet? It seems terribly hard to hush that many people.

        • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

          I will have a specific posts on these questions.

  • JL

    What makes more sense, to “assume” a random (deranged) individual intent on committing suicide shot a bunch of children and unarmed adults in an unprotected school or to “assume” government officials plotted such a heinous crime? I would say the former has much better odds despite the perceived government motives such as banning guns.

    I’m not saying the latter could not happen, but it would make much less sense if it did in my opinion.

    Some people are convinced the Apollo astronaut moon landing was a
    giant conspiracy (based on a guy trying to sell his video tape series).

    There are lots of conspiracies… people conspire for good or bad purposes regularly. Just as not all conspiracy theories are false… not all conspiracy theories are true either. Sometimes we just don’t know.

    In my opinion, it’s good to keep an open mind…. and I agree, Occam’s razor is a good approach.

    • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

      If they even bothered to produce a few dead bodies I would go with the deranged theory. But there is nothing. One of the key witnesses who apparently saw somebody was the custodian. He hasn’t been seen or heard since.

      One thing released in the CT data dump were three police video cams set up in different directions the parking lot. There is nothing in them, no children, no EMT vehicles, no evac. Just some police milling around or passing through. It was shockingly dull and quiet.

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    A big movie “Kill the Messenger” coming out in the fall with Jeremy Renner playing Gary Webb may bring this back into public consciousness.

    His editor on Gary Webb. Let me translate, “once we realized he had stumbled on a gamechanger it affected certain power people’s sensibilities and we received calls. But Gary just ignored us and went ahead anyway, so we fired his ass. ”

    Scott Herhold, Webb’s first editor at the Mercury-News, to write, “Gary Webb was a journalist of outsized talent. Few reporters I’ve known could match his nose for an investigative story. When he was engaged, he worked hard. He wrote well. But Webb had one huge blind side: He was fundamentally a man of passion, not of fairness. When facts didn’t fit his theory, he tended to shove them to the sidelines.” Herhold concluded, “He was no villain … He was no hero either. Take it from someone who knew him well.”

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Pultizer Prize reporter Gary Webb commentary on investigative journalism and CIA drug trafficking in 2004 shortly before being “suicided”. God bless you, RIP.

  • http://www.winteractionables.com/ Russ Winter

    Seem like others are confused as well. PLG is Platimum Group Metals on the Amex. Pilot has the same symbol. Answer is yes on both levels.

    • loantech

      Thanks Russ added 4k starter position on Pilot Gold.

  • loantech

    Russ a week or so ago I asked about buying PLG and I meant Pilot Gold. Were you saying to wait for around $1.00 USD to buy or were you referring to Platinum Group Metals?
    So current question is, is $1.40 CND a fair price for Pilot Gold at this point?